$12 Billion Midterm: Money Trail Reshapes US Politics

$12 Billion Midterm: Money Trail Reshapes US Politics

Union muscle, not paid ads, decided the costliest US election on record

The most expensive midterm election in American history has ended in a sweep for the Democratic Party, and the money trail behind the result says as much about the future of US politics as the vote counts themselves. Estimated spending approached $12 billion, up from roughly $4 billion in 2016. Yet the decisive force was not paid advertising but organizing: union mobilization, new voter networks, and campaign infrastructure that reached into states long written off by strategists.

The scale of the Republican defeat was staggering. Candidates at every level of government won by margins of seven to fourteen points or more, and no partisan operation or pundit predicted the full depth of the result. Democrats now hold 56 Senate seats and are set to hold nearly 260 in the House. They hold thirty governorships and full control of many swing state legislatures, while GOP supermajorities have been broken in key red states. Elon Musk alone donated $445 million to Republican campaigns, an outlay that failed to arrest the collapse.

The capital behind the Democratic wave came in a different form: labor. Union votes made up 16 percent of ballots cast, up five points from 2024. The AFL-CIO ran a historic midterm program across thirty-five states, while Michigan’s UAW knocked fifteen thousand doors and made more than 145,000 calls for Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed during his primary bid. New mobilizing networks helped drive near record turnout, including in Mississippi, where nearly half a million voters elected Scott Colom, the first black Senator since Reconstruction.

Historical sociologist Theda Skocpol, speaking to Phenomenal World editor Maya Adereth, framed the result as a landmark with long-term implications. She argued the wave paves the way for a repudiation of what she calls the Trumpian synthesis of plutocratic patrimonial corruption and MAGA racism. She was blunt about where the party’s money should now go. Democrats ought to fire most of the high-priced consultants who recommended spending on television ads just before elections, she said, and instead invest in sustained all-year organizing. Parties should not just appear before elections; they should be present in people’s day-to-day lives. That means passing popular measures one at a time and forcing Trump to veto them, maximizing state government powers to deliver visible wins, and investing resources into organizing across the South, particularly mobilizing black voters’ outrage over attacks on voting rights.

Skocpol’s account of why American parties behave as they do is, at bottom, an account of how resources have always flowed through them. US parties, she explained, are patronage parties rather than movement parties: the purpose behind capturing federal power has been to hand out goods, from post offices and services to pensions. After Reconstruction, when Black Americans were forced out of the electoral system in much of the country, Black associations remained active within the Republican Party because fraternal lodges and civic groups channeled resources to disenfranchised communities. Southern states saw Black Americans appointed as postmasters and customs collectors, and some as diplomats, with Black leaders maintaining a say in appointments until the early 1900s.

That patronage model has since mutated. In the Trump era, she argues, the Republican Party has moved from a model of party patronage to one of personal patronage. Donald Trump may be out of office, or dead, four years from now, but his sons will continue to be billionaires, profiting from the defense contracts they are getting today. The entire corporate sector is banking on direct links to the White House to manipulate government contracts and regulations. This, she notes, is fundamentally different from the 1930s to the 1960s, when organized labor and business organizations had strong sway in their respective parties, the closest the United States came to genuine class politics.

The right’s transformation has its own funding history. Two parallel developments radicalized the Republican Party from the early 2000s: the top-down Koch brothers network and the bottom-up Tea Party network. The Kochs built Americans for Prosperity and accumulated resources from millionaires and billionaires into an affiliated super PAC, operating, in Skocpol’s words, as a Leninist operation aiming to force the party against government spending and regulation of any sort. Their organizations claimed to speak for the Tea Parties but used them as foot soldiers. Yet the more popularly rooted, anti-immigrant Tea Party elements took the political lead, and in capturing that vote conservatives paved the way for MAGA.

By contrast, the Democratic financial story is one of misallocation. Blue-collar unions, once the party’s broadest organized base, chose to invest dwindling resources in Washington lobbying rather than sustaining their civic infrastructure, and have now virtually collapsed. The party’s organized constituencies are now largely led by professional, donor-operated advocacy operations with offices in Washington, claiming to speak for constituencies they never interact with. Reliance on litigation and congressional staff proved a fragile substitute for grassroots power, as courts were remade by the right.

Whether a redistributive agenda now returns may depend on whether parties and grassroots organizations can claim a durable role in configurations of power. Skocpol’s advice to organizers is direct: find out where people in your constituency hang out, keep them engaged year-round, and when you win, visibly deliver on practical priorities. A few well-timed words bandied by consultants, she said, will not do it.

Q&A

How much was spent in the midterm election and how does it compare to prior cycles?

Estimated spending approached $12 billion, up from roughly $4 billion in 2016, making it the most expensive midterm election in American history.

What did Elon Musk's $445 million in Republican donations achieve?

It failed to arrest the Republican collapse. Candidates at every level lost by margins of seven to fourteen points or more, and the decisive force was Democratic organizing, not paid advertising.

Where does Theda Skocpol say Democratic money should go now?

Fire most of the high-priced consultants who recommended late television ads, and instead invest in sustained all-year organizing, passing popular measures one at a time, maximizing state government powers, and organizing across the South, particularly black voters.

What does Skocpol mean by the shift from party patronage to personal patronage?

Republicans have moved from handing out goods through the party to personal patronage: Trump's sons will remain billionaires profiting from defense contracts, and the corporate sector is banking on direct White House links to manipulate contracts and regulations.