Expert Witness System Failed to Flag Banned Doctor

Expert Witness System Failed to Flag Banned Doctor

Disclosure breakdown left courts unaware of expert's clinical ban for over two years

The disclosure machinery of expert testimony in criminal courts failed at every checkpoint. A doctor central to two major prosecutions was, at the time he wrote his reports, barred from treating patients by his own hospital, and the system designed to surface such restrictions did not alert anyone for more than two years.

Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a paediatric endocrinologist at University College London hospitals trust (UCLH), was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 after the trust concluded his advice to child patients on insulin was not safe. Five months later he produced a crucial expert report for the Crown Prosecution Service in a Birmingham neglect case. His earlier evidence had helped convict the nurse Lucy Letby of murdering seven babies. Neither jury was told of his exclusion.

The operational sequence matters. UCLH’s medical director, Dr Tim Hodgson, informed the General Medical Council in March 2023 that the hospital could not “accept the level of risk Professor Hindmarsh appears to pose to children and young people”. In August 2023, Hindmarsh delivered the report that underpinned the prosecution of Damion and Tamara Thomas, accused of neglecting their 12-year-old son Joshua before his death. West Midlands police apparently were not told of the GMC investigation when he wrote it. The CPS West Midlands region office remained unaware of the investigation and of the concerns about his practice until December 2025, when Hindmarsh disclosed details after being asked.

By then the machinery had already run its course. Tamara Thomas was convicted in March of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect, and sentenced in June to three years and nine months. Damion Thomas was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of neglect, receiving two years and nine months. Lead investigator Vicki Harris cited Hindmarsh’s opinion after the convictions, saying expert medical evidence showed Joshua’s death would have been preventable had medical attention been sought earlier. The Thomases, who maintain their innocence, have applied to the court of appeal.

Under the criminal procedure rules, expert witnesses must disclose anything that might undermine their opinion or credibility, including regulatory disciplinary proceedings, and must do so “as soon as reasonably practicable”. Tim Green KC, a disclosure specialist, confirmed that standard. Hindmarsh does not appear to have informed police of his circumstances for more than two years after writing his report. The Guardian understands the CPS independently discovered the GMC restrictions in November 2025, asked police to raise it with him, and then decided it could still rely on him as its expert.

The timeline of the restrictions themselves shows a regulator and employer acting, but with limited practical effect. A medical practitioners tribunal ordered supervision in January 2023. In March 2023, Hodgson reported that Hindmarsh had breached that order and had independently advised two child patients to stop taking insulin at home; one child suffered an episode of diabetic ketoacidosis, though Hodgson said it was unclear whether this coincided with the alleged advice. The GMC sought suspension, but an April 2023 tribunal declined, ruling it disproportionate and noting the order would “not restrict his non-clinical work”. By then UCLH had already excluded Hindmarsh from treating patients altogether, so the stricter supervision had, in practice, no application.

The investigation never reached a final adjudication. Hindmarsh applied for voluntary erasure from the medical register, which was granted in November 2024, ending the process with no conclusion. When disclosure finally came, on 9 December 2025, shortly before the Thomases’ trial, his self-certificate mentioned the referral and two earlier tribunal rulings but omitted the April 2023 ruling, UCLH’s reported concerns, his exclusion from clinical practice, and the termination of his honorary contract at Great Ormond Street hospital in July 2022.

Meanwhile, the family learned of the investigation only after the verdicts. Alessandro Thomas, 27, representing his parents, said the first they heard of it was on 3 March, after Hindmarsh had given evidence, when the Guardian reported it. Their own lawyers, he said, chose not to inform them or challenge Hindmarsh’s credibility, apparently believing the judge would not allow it. “It turned out his medical judgment was not trusted by his own hospital,” Alessandro said. “This does not feel like justice.”

West Midlands police said it fulfilled its disclosure obligations, and the CPS said it met all its obligations and that no defence objections were raised. Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian’s questions.

In the Letby case, the stakes of these delivery failures are highest. Hindmarsh’s opinion that two babies were poisoned with insulin was crucial to convictions that carry 15 whole-life sentences. Seven experts have since told Letby’s lawyer, Mark McDonald, in submissions to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, that Hindmarsh’s analysis was wrong. The jury in that trial, which ran from October 2022 to August 2023, was never told of the investigation, the hospitals’ concerns, or the exclusion from practice. Whether the Court of Appeal now orders retrials may depend on how the system responds to the gap between what these rules required and what was actually delivered.

Q&A

When and why was Prof Peter Hindmarsh excluded from clinical practice?

UCLH excluded him in March 2023 after concluding his advice to child patients on insulin was not safe. Its medical director, Dr Tim Hodgson, told the GMC the hospital could not accept the level of risk he appeared to pose to children and young people.

What happened in the Birmingham neglect case involving the Thomases?

Hindmarsh's August 2023 report underpinned the prosecution of Damion and Tamara Thomas over the death of their 12-year-old son Joshua. Tamara Thomas was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect, sentenced to three years and nine months; Damion was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of neglect, receiving two years and nine months. They maintain their innocence and have applied to the court of appeal.

How did the GMC investigation conclude?

A tribunal ordered supervision in January 2023 and declined to suspend him in April 2023, ruling that disproportionate. Hindmarsh then applied for voluntary erasure from the medical register, granted in November 2024, ending the process with no final adjudication.

What is the significance for the Lucy Letby convictions?

Hindmarsh's opinion that two babies were poisoned with insulin was crucial to convictions carrying 15 whole-life sentences. Seven experts have since told Letby's lawyer, Mark McDonald, in submissions to the Criminal Cases Review Commission that his analysis was wrong, and the jury was never told of the investigation or his exclusion.