Anthropic's record IPO opens lower as AI jitters hit Wall St

Underwriting support withdrawn as investors question AI valuations

Anthropic's record IPO opens lower as AI jitters hit Wall St

Anthropic’s record-setting initial public offering, the largest listing on record after underwriters exercised an option for extra shares, opened on Wall Street under a cloud on Friday, with the stock falling roughly 10 percent from Thursday’s close to $87.28 and hovering near its $83 offering price. The debut had been positioned as a potential turning point for a sector struggling to regain its footing, but the outcome instead sharpened questions about whether the market’s appetite for artificial intelligence valuations can be sustained under scrutiny.

The institutional machinery surrounding the offering has already shifted. Morgan Stanley, the underwriter tasked with stabilizing Anthropic’s shares after the debut, closed its price-stabilization position, removing what had been a potential support pillar for the stock. That move leaves the company without one of the mechanisms typically used to steady a newly public share price, and analysts note that near-term volatility could persist as initial excitement fades and investors assess whether a valuation of roughly 40 times trailing 12-month sales can be justified.

The scale of the raise underscores the stakes. The offering raised $93.5 billion, surpassing the $85.7 billion haul from Elon Musk’s SpaceX, whose June listing was the second-biggest on record. As the first major machine-learning model developer to go public, Anthropic is widely treated as a proxy for the entire AI trade, which gives its listing significance well beyond a single company’s fortunes. Investors have drawn parallels between the two debuts, pointing to SpaceX’s sharp price swings after listing as reason for caution about buying Anthropic immediately. SpaceX shares themselves dropped over 6 percent.

Market participants framed the stumble as a judgment on the sector rather than the company. “Anthropic faded relatively quickly. I don’t think investors believe there’s something inherently wrong with the company, management or business. I think they’re just skeptical of this market,” said Robert Pavlik, senior portfolio manager at Dakota Wealth. David Miller, chief investment officer at Catalyst Funds, offered a similar reading: “Investors still believe in AI but are becoming more selective about what they will pay for that growth.”

Meanwhile, the pressure on the AI boom has built over the past month as concerns mount that spending on the technology, expected by some estimates to top $1 trillion this year, is failing to deliver returns quickly enough. Those worries have been compounded by political hurdles to data center construction and leadership instability at chip producer Nvidia.

The sell-off extended across the market’s most prominent names. Among the Magnificent Seven stocks, Nvidia dropped around 6 percent and Meta Platforms slipped nearly 3 percent, while Amazon and Microsoft registered losses of less than 1 percent each. Chipmakers also declined, with AMD and Marvell Technology down more than 8 percent each and Intel falling roughly 3 percent. Wall Street’s main benchmarks had closed sharply lower on Thursday, and futures indicated further falls on Friday.

Attention now turns to a potential listing by rival leader OpenAI, which could provide another test of investor appetite for AI stocks. OpenAI has signaled it may go public next year. Despite a strong pipeline of high-profile AI and infrastructure firms, many have delayed their IPO plans until 2027, a sign that the market’s reception of Anthropic may shape the timing decisions of others.

There are potential sources of support ahead. London-based analytics firm Intropic estimates that index-tracking funds could buy up to 30 percent of Anthropic’s shares by year-end, a flow of passive demand that could cushion the price. Retail investors, meanwhile, traded roughly $772 million of Anthropic stock on Thursday, the highest figure for an IPO debut since Vanda Research began tracking the data in 2012. Options trading, set to begin next week, is likely to add further volatility.

Advisers urged restraint. “There’s going to be some volatility like we had with SpaceX. A lot of people are going to have FOMO. I don’t think there’s any need to get on it on the first trade,” said Rob Hackel, CEO of financial advisory and brokerage firm RF Lafferty & Co. Kaush Amin, head of private market investing at US Bank Asset Management, said the current valuation “assumes years of rapid growth,” adding: “We favor patience on Anthropic and recommend evaluating the company as it reports public results.”

Anthropic held a fully diluted valuation of about $1.6 trillion at the latest price, with a market capitalization of $1.2 trillion based on shares outstanding. “It’s not a good environment for Anthropic at the moment,” said Carsten Hesse, head of index events at Berenberg, summing up the immediate challenge facing the largest listing on record. Whether the underwriting and index flows now in place can steady the share price, or whether OpenAI’s mooted listing meets a cooler reception, will be the next test of the market’s confidence in AI valuations.

Q&A

How much did Anthropic's IPO raise and how does it compare to other listings?

The offering raised $93.5 billion, surpassing the $85.7 billion haul from Elon Musk's SpaceX, whose June listing was the second-biggest on record.

What role did Morgan Stanley play after the debut?

Morgan Stanley, the underwriter tasked with stabilizing Anthropic's shares, closed its price-stabilization position, removing a potential support pillar for the stock.

How did other major stocks perform during the sell-off?

Nvidia dropped around 6 percent, Meta Platforms slipped nearly 3 percent, Amazon and Microsoft lost less than 1 percent each, while AMD and Marvell Technology fell more than 8 percent and Intel roughly 3 percent.

What potential sources of support exist for Anthropic's share price?

Intropic estimates index-tracking funds could buy up to 30 percent of Anthropic's shares by year-end, and retail investors traded roughly $772 million of the stock on Thursday, the highest IPO debut figure since 2012.